Did hermits really live in caves?

Simon Edward • November 11, 2024
BOOK TICKETS

Throughout history, hermits have lived in caves. Uncover the fascinating stories of 6 cave-dwelling recluses.



A man is kneeling in front of a fireplace in a cave.

Hermits are people who retire from the world and live alone, often for religious reasons. Many live in purpose-built dwellings called hermitages, often (but not always) connected to a nearby monastery.


But did you know that throughout history, hermits have also lived in caves?


Your first thought might be why anyone would choose to live in a damp, narrow, rocky environment like a cave. The simple answer is that most of them were living there as a form of penance – simplifying their lives as much as possible and denying themselves earthly pleasures as a way of serving God.


Others sought out caves as a way of retreating from the world. Others still lived in caves temporarily for speleological purposes – that's "cave science" to the rest of us.


Want to learn more about the fascinating characters who went off-grid and underground? Here are six of our favourites.


1. Cornelius the Baker


Dale Abbey is a small village in Derbyshire, not far from Ilkeston. To the south is Hermit's Wood, a peaceful spot of ancient beeches and oaks.


Hermit's Wood holds a secret: the Hermit's Cave, once the abode of a local baker turned mystic.


The story goes that a Derby baker called Cornelius was visited in a vision by the Virgin Mary, who told him to go to Dale Abbey, "where thou shalt serve my Son and me in solitude".


Cornelius swapped his floury apron for a rocky retreat, digging himself a small dwelling where he lived and prayed.


One day, Cornelius was found by local landowner Ralph Fitz Geremund. He was so moved by the hermit's story that he bestowed money on him – money that let Cornelius move into more salubrious digs in a small chapel.


2. Giovanni Maria de Agostini


Giovanni Maria de Agostini was one of history's best-travelled hermits. But for three years in the 1860s, he lived in a cave in the mountains of Sangre de Cristo, New Mexico.


There, he carried out his daily devotions, walking to Mass in Las Vegas, New Mexico, every Sunday. He foraged for food and collected water from a spring.


A large body of water surrounded by trees and rocks.

Agostini's life was driven by faith and solitude. He claims to have begun "to incline toward a solitary life" at the tender age of five. He never joined a parish or monastery, always beating his own path.


His story ends in 1869 when he was killed. We don't know why he was attacked, or by whom, but records show that he died with his crucifix in his hand.


3. Saint Simeon Stylites the Elder


If you've heard of Saint Simeon Stylites the Elder, it's probably as the Christian ascetic who lived on top of a pillar. But he also spent part of his worshipful life in a cave.


Simeon was born around 390 AD. He entered a monastery as a teenager. However, his pursuit of abstinence was so fanatical that he was expelled by his fellow monks.


He moved from the monastery to a cave. But his deeply-held wish for solitude was frustrated by visitors asking him for counsel or healing.


Sick of the spotlight, Simeon took his devotions up a pillar near Aleppo in modern-day Syria. His years atop the pillar gave the name "stylite" to any subsequent pillar-saint. 


4. John Sparkes (or Sparke)


Unlike our hermits so far, we know almost nothing about John Sparkes. Nevertheless, his story is a curious slice of mediaeval history.


In Bristol, there's a Quaker burial ground opposite St Mary Redcliffe Church. Nearby, there's a small cave dug into the sandstone of Redliffe Hill.


Eagle-eyed visitors will see a plaque that tells a fascinating tale. In 1346, Thomas Lord Berkeley installed John Sparkes there. His job? To pray for Berkeley and his family.


Berkeley was in search of redemption, having been tried as an accessory to the murder of King Edward II.


The cave was used as a hermitage after Sparkes's death, all the way up to the 17th century.


His story is not unlike that of garden hermits or ornamental hermits. These were people encouraged to live alone on the estates of wealthy landowners. Francis of Paola, for instance, lived in a cave on his father's estate back in the 15th century.


A rocky cliff with a cave in the middle of it surrounded by plants.

4. Timon of Athens


Timon of Athens was the Victor Meldrew of his day. He was a citizen of Athens in the fourth century BC with a legendary contempt for humanity.


In Shakespeare's play
Timon of Athens, he starts off as a wealthy and generous gentleman – perhaps a little too generous. He's surrounded by yes-men who sponge off him until he's broke.


Filled with rage, he denounces not only his so-called friends but also mankind in general, retreating to a cave in the wilderness. "Be abhorr'd," he rails, "all feasts, societies, and throngs of men!"


There, he lives off roots, discovers a treasure trove, subsidises a rebel army and dies in the wilderness – not quite the life of quiet isolation he was hoping for.


5. Geoff Workman


In 1963, Yorkshireman Geoff Workman broke the world record for time spent in total isolation underground – and he did it right here at Stump Cross Caverns.


First question: why?


According to Geoff, his subterranean sojourn was scientific research. He wanted to learn more about the caves, as well as the effects of isolation on the human mind and body.


A
newsreel from the time, however, suggests that his stint as a hermit was connected to the Cold War. At that time, the possibility of nuclear war was on everyone's minds. Could it be, as the newsreel says, that Geoff "wanted to prove that if we had to go into caves in a nuclear war, all we need to do is wrap up warm and take down a lot of food"?


Whatever his reasons, Geoff's record stayed unbroken until
the Spanish athlete Beatriz Flamini spent 500 days in a cave near Granada, Spain.


When her team came to collect her, Flamini is reported to have said, "Already? Surely not."


Are you looking for family
cave adventures in the UK? Stump Cross Caverns is an ancient cave network buried deep underneath the Yorkshire Dales. You won't find any hermits here – but you will find prehistoric secrets, amazing rock formations and lots of things to see and do. Book your tickets online to unlock exclusive discounts.


Explore engaging Stone Age project ideas for your Year 3s, with creative activities, teaching tips
By Simon Edward May 1, 2026
Explore engaging Stone Age project ideas for your Year 3s, with creative activities, teaching tips and inspiring field trip opportunities.
Discover great restaurants and eateries near Stump Cross Caverns, from pubs to cafes – all perfect
By Simon Edward April 27, 2026
Discover great restaurants and eateries near Stump Cross Caverns, from pubs to cafes – all perfect for refuelling after exploring the Dales.
Discover Stone Age dietary and dental habits, early methods of cleaning teeth, and what cavemen used
By Simon Edward April 24, 2026
Discover Stone Age dietary and dental habits, early methods of cleaning teeth, and what cavemen used instead of toothpaste.
Discover the best apps for navigating the Yorkshire Dales, with maps, weather and safety tools
By Simon Edward April 20, 2026
Discover the best apps for navigating the Yorkshire Dales, with maps, weather and safety tools to help you explore with confidence.
Discover scenic wild swimming spots in the Yorkshire Dales, with essential safety tips
By Simon Edward April 17, 2026
Discover scenic wild swimming spots in the Yorkshire Dales, with essential safety tips to help you enjoy the water responsibly.
Discover the best rainy day activities in North Yorkshire, from museums to cosy cafes and caves
By Simon Edward April 13, 2026
Discover the best rainy day activities in North Yorkshire, from museums to cosy cafes and caves that are perfect for April weather.
Planning a birthday party for an inquisitive mind? Discover creative ideas
By Oliver Bowerman April 10, 2026
Planning a birthday party for an inquisitive mind? Discover creative ideas to make your child's special day educational and fun.
Get ahead with your weird and wonderful cave knowledge. Learn the amazing answers
By Oliver Bowerman April 6, 2026
Get ahead with your weird and wonderful cave knowledge. Learn the amazing answers to some of the most common questions kids ask about caves.
Discover beautiful wildflower meadows in the Yorkshire Dales this spring
By Simon Edward March 31, 2026
Discover beautiful wildflower meadows in the Yorkshire Dales this spring – from limestone valleys to hay fields near Stump Cross Caverns.
Discover how Yorkshire does Easter differently, from folk theatre and unique baking customs
By Oliver Bowerman March 30, 2026
Discover how Yorkshire does Easter differently, from folk theatre and unique baking customs to springtime sparkle beneath the ground.
More Posts